Craft·2 min read·

The details users never see (but always feel)

People rarely notice a good detail. They notice that a product feels right, and they cannot tell you why.

There is one question I have been chasing since I started: why do some products just feel right?

It is rarely the big idea. Two products can do the same job, and one feels solid while the other feels slightly off. Ask people why and they cannot say. They are feeling details they never saw.

Nobody was checking

I taught myself to build websites the strict way: XHTML and web standards, at a time when nobody was checking. A careless page and a correct one looked the same in the browser. I did it properly anyway, and the habit stayed.

That is still how I think about detail. It is the work you do when no one would catch you skipping it.

What a detail looks like

A date picker. What people see is a calendar. The work is every state around it: no date chosen yet, a range that crosses two months, a date that is not allowed. Skip one, and that is the one a user runs into. On one engagement that picker was my first test. I designed every state, and engineering shipped it as drawn.

A wall-sized screen. It was designed before it physically existed. Once it was installed we had one week on the real thing, and that week went on sizes and cropped edges. Things nobody could see in the file were obvious on twenty metres of screen.

An Arabic sentence that begins with an English word. Left alone, its full stop jumps to the wrong end of the line. Nobody reports that as a bug. They just read the product as a little less careful.

Why it is worth the time

Each of these is small. But people meet them one after another, and they add up to a feeling.

When the small things are right, people assume the big things are right too. When they are not, people start doubting everything else. Craft is not decoration. It is how trust is built or broken.

Details also disappear easily. A design can be right and the built screen can drift from it, a few pixels at a time. So someone has to check the real thing, not the file. On my teams, design signs off the built screen before it ships.

The condition

Outside work, I am the person who opens a new app and looks at the spacing before the features. I notice the logo that is slightly off-centre in someone else’s presentation. I say nothing. Usually.

It is a condition, and there is no cure.

You will never notice most of it. You will feel all of it.

Samer HaddadUI/UX Manager, leading design for AI products